Beneath a deceptive calm, it uncovers a core of fear and loathing as ominous as the backwoods world of "Winter's Bone."
Stephen Holden - New York Times
Boldly succinct yet confident enough to take its time.
Mark Holcomb - Village Voice
"Small Town Murder Songs" moves so deliberately, with such confident authority, that every small event takes on cumulative significance...
Joe Morgenstern - Wall Street Journal
With his second feature, GassDonnelly achieves that longed-for thing, a whole greater than the parts, one in which each disparate element complements the other.
John Anderson - Variety
Rarely does cinema sight and sound mesh as boldly as this, and it's all to the good.
Peter Howell - Toronto Star
STMS succeeds as an Ontario Gothic mood piece, a story of alternately repressed and exploding passion.
Stephen Cole - Globe and Mail
An effective ensemble backed by a bracingly haunting soundtrack strike a compelling chord in this rural Canadian crime drama.
Michael Rechtshaffen - Hollywood Reporter
... the film is only an hour-and-a-quarter long, and that's just as well; spells are hard to sustain. Yet it's big enough.
Richard T. Jameson - Parallax View
Atmospherically steeped in rural noir. . .Stormare's agonized face keeps the focus on more a tormented character study than a mystery. . .greatly heightened by rootsy songs.
Nora Lee Mandel - Film-Forward.com
Peter Stormare is a limited actor who only manages to exude the resolute nothingness of the role.
Chuck Bowen - Slant Magazine
The soundtrack ... goes miles toward making what would be an unmanageably dour experience into an acute emotional resonance; the songs are freed to say more than the characters onscreen.
Alison Willmore - AV Club
A redemption parable that occasionally finds balladlike lyricism in its biblical solemnity and oddball Lynchian rhythms.
David Fear - Time Out
Stormare's performance towers over the flimsy story. Besides the effective ensemble acting, another asset is the outstanding cinematography. This captivatingly haunting crime drama never gets tiresome and knows when to bring the...
Keith Cohen - Entertainment Spectrum
Why are recent movies about small towns with murderous secrets so good?
Jason Heck - Kansas City Star
A lawman seeking redemption can't seem to escape sin in Ed Gass-Donnelly's haunting, rural drama.
Pam Grady - Boxoffice Magazine
While it's easy to admire the unique stylistic accents director Ed Gass-Donnelly fearlessly applies to his northern Ontario murder mystery, it's not so easy to enjoy them.
Radheyan Simonpillai - NOW Toronto
The force in Stormare's performance is enough to suggest we've witnessed only a fraction of the character's anguish.
Jason Anderson - eye WEEKLY
...Small Town Murder Songs [features] an oppressively deliberate pace that effectively holds the viewer at arm's length from start to finish...
David Nusair - Reel Film Reviews
For all that Small Town Murder Songs hints at, there isn't enough delivery here.
Liz Braun - Jam! Movies