- New York Times
[It] does an excellent job of recapitulating the controversies surrounding the album's creation without bearing down too heavily on old news, while subtly taking Mr. Simon's side against his critics.
Stephen Holden - New York Times
It's a pleasant surprise that Under African Skies not only draws attention to the controversy surrounding its subject matter but digs into it a little.
Tim Grierson - Village Voice
A harmonious, fair-minded, energetic and enlightening portrait of one masterpiece's moment in time.
Joe Neumaier - New York Daily News
Under African Skies is appreciably smarter than most celebrity musician docus.
Rob Nelson - Variety
A pure-bliss celebration of Paul Simon's landmark album Graceland coupled with an interesting if not unbiased look at the controversy surrounding its release...
John DeFore - Hollywood Reporter
Powered by Paul Simon's brilliance, Under African Skies is a cultural lightning bolt that soars on its music and an unshakable belief in the transcendence of art.
Peter Travers - Rolling Stone
The affection between the musicians and Simon is clear. The portrait that emerges time and again is personal and a reflection of the realities of apartheid.
Betsy Sharkey - Los Angeles Times
UNDER AFRICAN SKIES is much smarter and more profound than most music documentaries. It's a powerful, beautifully executed film that entertains, informs and questions.
Meredith Borders - Badass Digest
It's a blissful film, this work by Berlinger and co., a sheer privilege for the viewer to spend such quality time UNDER AFRICAN SKIES.
Jason Gorber - Twitch
This absorbing documentary takes an up-close and intimate look at the musicians' creative process, then zooms out to recall the political turmoil that this landmark album left in its wake.
Michael Sauter - Film Journal International
Under African Skies takes what could have been a puff piece glossing over the protestations related to Graceland and teaches the controversy.
Mark Pfeiffer - Reel Times: Reflections on Cinema
Rich Cline - Shadows on the Wall
The result is doubly satisfying: We get not only a trenchant political drama but a bang-up concert film as well.
Peter Rainer - Christian Science Monitor
Under African Skies is less interested in hagiography than in the moral ambiguities of making art.
Eric Hynes - Time Out New York
It does lightly suggest scintillating questions about the responsibility artists have in reflecting current political moments in their music.
Kenji Fujishima - Slant Magazine
Berlinger's doc expertly captures the debate of the time and where it's at now, 25 years later.
Christopher Campbell - Movies.com
What's most exciting about Under African Skies is how it engages with whether artists have social and political responsibilities, and if so, what those might entail.
Noel Murray - AV Club