Turn Advertising Off
 
    Archive      DVD News      TV News      Features      Interviews      Deals      Dollars      Announcements      Top Stories

EXCLUSIVE: Will Chris Nolan Recast the Joker for Batman 3 or Will the Riddler Take His Place?

Source:  MovieWeb.com
Movie PictureWhile conducting interviews with the cast of The Dark Knight this afternoon, I got a chance to chat with director Christopher Nolan and Gary Oldman about the proposed third segment of their supposed Batman trilogy. While none of us in attendance really wanted to dwell on the death of Heath Ledger, Oldman offered his thoughts on the actor's portrayal of the Joker, calling it the scariest on-screen performance he's ever seen.

He even went on to compare it to his own work as Sirius Black, saying, "Sirius Black might scare six year olds, but he doesn't scare nine year olds. It's hard to scare kids these days. Heath does. He scares everybody. This is one of the most frightening performances I have ever seen put on film." When asked if he thought they should recast Ledger for the third film, or just not include the character, Gary thought it was a good idea, "I don't see why not. I mean, they did it with Katie Holmes' character. I understand that this is a different circumstance, but I think another actor could do the job. I think Heath would want another actor to do the job."

Oldman then took a moment to think about it some more, "Maybe we don't need the Joker. Because we'll have The Riddler." Yes, Oldman alluded to the fact that The Riddler may in fact be the next on-screen Batman villain.

When I asked if he, himself, wanted to come back for a third segment, he smiled coyly, "We don't really know if Nolan is coming back." He then shook his head. "I guess I have to come back." He then put his hand to the side of his mouth as if to hide the next line from everybody, "Nolan will come back for a third one. I think we all have to." It is well known that Oldman tried to get out of appearing in The Dark Knight, but his contract wouldn't allow it.

Next, I asked Christopher Nolan if he wanted to come back for a third Batman film, and he said that he wasn't sure that he wanted to come back, "I don't know. I take my projects one at a time, and I am not thinking about that right now. I don't know if I want to come back." After that, I asked, "If you do choose to make a third Batman film, do you think that you would recast for the Joker? Or will he not appear in the film?"

Nolan's replay, "I don't know. I honestly have not taken a moment away from what is going on with the film now to even think about that. I don't know. I simply don't know."

The Dark Knight opens July 18th, 2008.


Page: of 29 Total Pages

870 Comments


November 20th, 2009 8:26pm
I welcome the riddler as the next villian, but u have to recast joker sooner or later, why not introduce the new joker sometime in the third movie?
  (Delete)
November 20th, 2009 5:06pm
knobie09, are you like, obsessed with keeping this thread going with zero data about #3's story in the past 17 months since this was posted? lolz :P
  (Delete)
November 17th, 2009 10:40pm
RECAST!!!
  (Delete)
November 16th, 2009 5:47pm
what could be the theme for batman 3

batman begins-fear
the dark knight-chaos
third movie-???

any sggestions or ideas?
  (Delete)
November 16th, 2009 10:27am
Joker isn't the best villain for this particular universe and I am surprised Nolan made him fit in and tweak him so perfectly not to mention Ledgers passionate performance.

However, I don't want so necessarily see the Riddler in this one. I'd much rather see a character like Hush, who has a personal vendetta on Batman, not on the entire city. Someone who is not a lunatic who thinks in advance but who knows he's in control and isn't a player in Batman's world. He's the guy moving the pieces. And the Hush character would be perfect. Thats me.
  (Delete)
November 12th, 2009 2:23pm
Like i said before keep The Joker in the movie as a heard of villain like he is working in the shadows sending tapes and stuff to the news or cops taunting the city and keeping them on edge, concentrate on another villain right now and end it with the way they ended Batman Begins leading in the 4th film " hopefully" back to The Joker
  (Delete)
November 11th, 2009 8:59pm
Don't recast. The Joker should be mentioned as being in Arkham. Move on with the Riddler and Catwoman. That make a good movie.

And no R rated Batman. That's just a terrible idea.
  (Delete)
November 8th, 2009 12:55am
I HAVE FAITH IN NOLAN AND WAT HE MAY HAVE PLANNED FOR THE THIRD { AND IF MAY BE, THE FINAL FILM } THEY MAY MENTION THE JOKER IN THE NEXT FILM OR NOT, BUT ONCE THE THIRD ONE COMES OUT, DONT GO AND JUMP TO JUDGE IT JUST CAUSE HE DOESNT MAKE AN APPEARANCE, IF NOLAN FEELS HE SHOULD MOVE ON FROM THAT CHARACTER TO THE NEXT VILLIAN, I THINK ITS A GOOD IDEA, THAT WAY WE CAN FOCUS ON THIS FILM BEING ON ITS OWN LIKE WE HAVE WITH BEGINS AND THE DARK KNIGHT...DONT DOUBT HIM YET PEOPLE, IM SURE HELL MAKE SENSE OF THINGS AND STILL HAVE A TRICK UP HIS SLEEVE
  (Delete)
November 7th, 2009 3:07am
i get what your saying but the way Heath Ledger portrayed this character no one is gonna be able to top it. not well the memory and performance of a lifetime is still fresh in their head. Some other actor will play the part for sure but every time they are show on screen Heath will come to mind. For now The Joker should only be mentioned in the next film as a villain who operates in the distant. Defiantly not a main character. Someone spoken of. Let's face it with his one time performance as this character he set the bar pretty high.
  (Delete)
November 2nd, 2009 10:33am
It's funny how everyone was against Heath's involvement in the first place, and the very mention of a recast for one of the most iconic villians of all time gets everyone's panties in a wad. I understand Heath's performance was great, no, it was superb, but saying that nobody can top it, let alone atempt to recreate the bases of the character from the dark knight is just naive and ignorrant. The Harley Quinn story line seems probable, but give Christopher Nolan credit, the man knows what he's doin. He's done justice thus far, let us see what he does next.
  (Delete)
October 28th, 2009 10:59pm
CaptainQuirk i like the story god knows its one of my favs how the joker twist Harley into his world, i mean the film is not being done for a few years, i just think if they do recast the joker it in my opinion and personal taste just wont add up. Heath did such a great performance, in my mind i don't think id be satisfied with someone playing the role a hundred percent, i agree the story has to go on but you get what im trying to say. im my mind his performance was flawless i don't think anyone is gonna top it in my opinion and for what id expect from the character when Heath set the bar so high when it comes to craft,drive, and passion for the role and character. But that's me i think most of us agree, he did a brilliant job the first time and the pure amazement of his portrayal of this character was so astounding we just cant see anyone else filling the void.
  (Delete)
October 28th, 2009 10:19am
I think The Joker must be recast for the third movie. I appreciate the loyalty that some people are showing towards Heath's performance but saying it can't be topped is nonsense. Daniel Day Lewis (arguably the greatest character actor ever) would do an amazing job. I reckon the story should feature The Joker being treated in Arkham Asylum by Dr. Harleen Quinzel (aka Harley Quinn), with him slowly manipulating her to become his pawn on the streets of Gotham, and with her mainly attempting to finish his intentions of killing Batman. I also think The Penguin should feature in it. Not Tim Burton's stupid portrayal of him, more like a ruthless mob boss who has taken full advantage of Gotham while Batman has been laying low from the authorities. Possible cast: Harley Quinn - Brittany Murphy (Girl, Interrupted proves her psychotic credentials). The Penguin - Philip Seymour Hoffman (there should be no disputing this).
  (Delete)
October 26th, 2009 4:51pm
Joker being cast has nothing to do with Heath's perfprmance... Heath did not make the joker DC did, and if they want to recast him, and they will so get over it, they most certainly will. As for who the new joker should be, way too early... but if I had my pic, Nolan almost went with Sean Penn before he picked Heath, might be interesting to see.
  (Delete)
October 22nd, 2009 8:38am
why does everyone want the recast? Heaths was a ground breaking performance that can't be topped, only diminished. Joker doesn't need to be in it, and saying penguin or riddler should is stupid. Penguin wouldn't fit the mood of Nolan's Batman, and Riddler would either be too similar to joker or just pale in comparison to him. Hush would be the best choice, He knows Bruce as well as Batman, he has a hatred for him thats been brewing since they were children, and he's the flip side of Bruce. Then bring in some muscle for the action, like firefly or Bane, who could both be done brilliantly in Nolans universe without being silly.
  (Delete)
October 22nd, 2009 1:10am
you guys are insane thinking anyone can tops heath's performance. when it happens and you know it will and it screws up im gonna be laughing my ass off. i think the only way to do it is to name drop him in the movie from time to time to keep the character in the story. for now it cant be done
  (Delete)
October 19th, 2009 3:20pm
and yes he was riddler in an earlier batman still better cast as joker
  (Delete)
October 19th, 2009 3:19pm
recast, no brokeback mountain joker, no micheal jackson pedo freddy. RECAST! I still think Jim Carrey would make a pimp ass joker this time around he could always be in the shadows. they need to reboot batman and make an R rated hardcore batman instead of this crap. Bring back burtons music make it like arkham asylum graphic novel.
  (Delete)
October 7th, 2009 12:33am
I would include the Joker again, but not right away in this film. I would take my time creating a great story and getting as many of the popular original realistic characters. Catwoman would be a bad choice right now. He just lost his love interest, you dont want to give him one right away. I would probably do either the Riddler or Penguin next and the try and incorporate the Joker back in when you know without a shadow of a doubt you found someone who can do as good of a job as Heath did and capture the same type of Joker he did so the story makes sense
  (Delete)
September 23rd, 2009 9:30pm
...AND THE PENGUIN TOO!!! but remember... DON'T KILL'EM LIKE IN "BATMAN" & "BATMAN RETURNS"!!! PLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  (Delete)
September 23rd, 2009 9:26pm
YES!!! I MEANT RECAST THE JOKER!!! believe it,or not.
  (Delete)
September 21st, 2009 7:35pm
RECAST!!!
  (Delete)
September 21st, 2009 7:33pm
RECAST!!!
  (Delete)
September 16th, 2009 8:35am
if you include the penguin,please don't kill'im either like in "BATMAN RETURNS"!!!!
  (Delete)
September 16th, 2009 8:33am
RECAST!!!
  (Delete)
September 16th, 2009 8:31am
RECAST!!!
  (Delete)
September 16th, 2009 8:31am
RECAST!!! but please... don't kill'im again just like in "BATMAN"!!!
  (Delete)
August 21st, 2009 12:11pm
I'm down for a catwomen villian or even a killer croc villian, and as for the revilance to lucious talkin about the body suit, won't rpotect from dogs, but maybe big cats, don't be retarded.
  (Delete)
August 13th, 2009 11:29pm
They should do the Riddler & The penguin that would be something different...
  (Delete)
July 26th, 2009 7:31am
Johnny Depp is such a lazy choice! Why does he have to be cast in everything that is slightly quirky??
  (Delete)
July 26th, 2009 7:27am
So stupid.
  (Delete)
Page: of 29 Total Pages

User Name:
Password:
 
Don"t have an account?
Get One Now!
LATEST COMMENTED STORIES
MOST ACTIVE IN THE LAST 10 DAYS
MOST COMMENTED STORIES OF ALL TIME
TOP FILM STORIES
Movieweb's 2009 Blu-ray Holiday Gift Guide!
MovieWeb's 2009 DVD Holiday Gift Guide
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Viggo Mortensen and Cast Travel on The Road
Join the The Twilight Saga: New Moon Review Party!
Win Huge Prizes from Ninja Assassin!
EXCLUSIVE: J.J. Abrams Goes Talks Star Trek And Beyond!
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: First Look at the Indie Film Fix
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: John Woo Visits Red Cliff
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: The Blind Side Cast Interview Featurette
EXCLUSIVE: Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans Interviews!
EXCLUSIVE: Lluis Homar & Blanca Portillo Talk Broken Embraces
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Carla Gugino Is One of the Women in Trouble
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Hal Holbrook Stands in That Evening Sun
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Pirate Radio Cast Interview Featurette
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: The Messenger Cast Interviews!
EXCLUSIVE: Jason Schwartzman Talks The Fantastic Mr. Fox
EXCLUSIVE: John Cusack & Amanda Peet Battle the Year 2012
CONTEST: Win Huge Prizes from The Blind Side!
Win the Official Pirate Radio Soundtrack
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Brand New Brothers TV Spot!
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: New Women in Trouble Clip
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Watch the Transylmania TV Spot
Bruckheimer & Mechner Talk Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Fall Into This New Collapse Clip!
EXCLUSIVE: Grant Heslov Talks The Men Who Stare at Goats
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Gentlemen Broncos Cast Interviews
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Sean Patrick Flanery and Norman Reedus Are Back in The Boondock Saints II: All Saints Day
EXCLUSIVE: VIDEO: Corey Feldman Talks Lost Boys 3: The Thirst
Become a MovieWeb Fan on Facebook!
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Creators Discuss Michael Jackson's This Is It!
Watch the Official Full-Length Avatar Trailer Right Now!!
EXCLUSIVE: Dolph Lundgren Talks Command Performance!
EXCLUSIVE: Dolph Lundgren on The Expendables Sequel & More!
EXCLUSIVE: First Look At The Boondock Saints II: All Saints Day!
Win A Unique Prize from Boondock Saints II: All Saints Day
Win Huge Prizes from The Box!
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Ti West Resides in The House of the Devil
EXCLUSIVE: Paranormal Activity's Katie Featherston & Micah Sloat
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Astro Boy Cast & Crew Interview Featurette
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Visit Fezziwig's in Disney's a Christmas Carol
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Saw VI Cast Interview Featurette
CONTEST: Win Huge Prizes from Saw VI!
EXCLUSIVE: Richard Harrah Takes Us Deep Into The Canyon
Win Big Prizes from Cirque du Freak: The Vampire's Assistant
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Where the Wild Things Are Cast Featurette
Win Great Prizes from Law Abiding Citizen
EXCLUSIVE: Harold Ramis Talks Ghostbusters 3 and Meatballs
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Peter Jackson Talks The Hobbit!
NEW FEATURE! Create Lists! Build Your DVD Collection and More!
NEW FEATURE! Watch Full-Length Movies and TV Shows!
LATEST FILM NEWS
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Viggo Mortensen and Cast Travel on The Road
The acclaimed actor, along with his director and co-star discuss their new post-apocalyptic film.
HEY, PAULINGTON: New Moon, Ninja Assassin, and Thanksgiving DVDs!
Paulington answers all of your questions in this life advice column for the true cinephile!
The Full-Length Season of the Witch Trailer Is Here
Take a look at the trailer from this new film starring Nicolas Cage.
Go Behind-the-Scenes of The Wolfman!
Watch this new two-minute featurette on the making of Joe Johnston's film.
New Sherlock Holmes International Featurette!
We have a new video glimpse inside Guy Ritchie's upcoming film.
CONTEST: Win Huge Prizes from Ninja Assassin!
We're giving away Stealth Ninja Backpacks, T-shirts and much more.
Megan Fox Has a 'Great Part' in Transformers 3
Director Michael Bay speaks about his controversial star.
The Twilight Saga: New Moon Breaks Midnight Showing Record
The film takes in a whopping $26.3 million from just midnight screenings alone.
 Click Here! for our complete news archive.
TOP DVD STORIES
Movieweb's 2009 Blu-ray Holiday Gift Guide!
MovieWeb's 2009 DVD Holiday Gift Guide
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Angels & Demons Special Feature Clip
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: New Megafault DVD Special Feature Clip
EXCLUSIVE: J.J. Abrams Goes Talks Star Trek And Beyond!
It's A Very Sunny Christmas with Rob McElhenney & Glen Howerton
J.J. Abrams Boldly Talks Star Trek DVD and Blu-ray
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Get Your First Look at Deadline!
CONTEST: Win Huge from Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Watch Our It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia: A Very Sunny Christmas DVD Clip Right Now!
CONTEST: Win Star Trek: The Art of The Film!
CONTEST: Bring Home the Outrageous Bruno on DVD
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Hit The Open Road with This New DVD Clip
EXCLUSIVE: First Look at a Fight Club Blu-ray Commentary Clip!
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Brand New Up Special Feature Clip
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: New Wrong Turn at Tahoe DVD Clip
Win Fight Club 10th Anniversary Blu-ray!
Win a Spread Poster Signed by Ashton Kutcher!
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: New G.I. Joe: The Complete Series DVD Clip
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Forrest Gump Blu-ray Special Feature Clip!
Hasbro & Legacy FX Talk G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra DVD
EXCLUSIVE: Shawn Ryan Reminisces on The Shield
CONTEST: Win Aliens in the Attic on Blu-ray!
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: The Cove DVD Trailer!
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: New Aliens in the Attic Special Feature Clip
Become a MovieWeb Fan on Facebook!
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Edward James Olmos Gets Fired Up About Battlestar Gallactica: The Plan!
EXCLUSIVE: Dolph Lundgren Talks Command Performance!
EXCLUSIVE: Erick Avari Talks Stargate: 15th Anniversary Edition
EXCLUSIVE: Ellen Jin Over Talks Tinker Bell and the Lost Treasure
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Command Performance DVD Red-Band Clip
CONTEST: Win Battlestar Galactica: The Plan on DVD
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: New Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs DVD Clip
EXCLUSIVE: Tibor Takacs Takes Us Back Through The Gate
EXCLUSIVE: Tamer Hassan Talks Wrong Turn 3: Left for Dead
Take Home Orphan on DVD!
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: New Wrong Turn 3: Left for Dead DVD Clip
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Stargate 15th Anniversary Blu-ray Clip
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Watch the First 7 Minutes of Adoration!
Win Drag Me to Hell on DVD
Win South Park: Bigger, Longer and Uncut on Blu-ray
EXCLUSIVE: Quinn Lord Wrecks Havoc in Trick 'r Treat
NEW FEATURE! Create Lists! Build Your DVD Collection and More!
LATEST DVD NEWS
Movieweb's 2009 Blu-ray Holiday Gift Guide!
Find the perfect hi-def gift for that someone special in your life this holiday season.
MovieWeb's 2009 DVD Holiday Gift Guide
Take a look at all of the hottest items you could be wrapping or unwrapping this holiday season.
Tanit Phoenix Signs on for Lost Boys 3: The Thirst
The South African actress will play a woman seeking Edgar Frog's services.
Tyler Perry's I Can Do Bad All by Myself Comes to DVD and Blu-ray on January 12th
We have all the details on the latest film from Tyler Perry in both formats.
Surrogates Brings the Robotic Drama to DVD and Blu-ray on January 26th
We have all the details on Bruce Willis' new film in both formats.
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Brand New Angels & Demons Special Feature Clip
Take a look inside this brand new DVD before it hits the shelves everywhere.
IFC Films to Stream Content Through Netflix
The independent studio has struck a deal to bring their films instantly to Netflix subscribers.
Up Lands Atop the Home Video Sales Charts
The Pixar film is the top-selling DVD and Blu-ray disc for last week.
 Click Here! for our complete news archive.
LATEST TV NEWS
Watch the Final Seinfeld Reunion Commercial for Curb Your Enthusiasm!
The last time you'll see the Seinfeld cast together is on this Sunday's season finale episode of Curb Your Enthusiasm!
Joel Wyman and Jeff Pinkner Talk About Fringe
The executive producers of the popular series talks about the season.
Sam Shepard to Star in EPIX's Tough Trade
The actor is set to star in the first original series.
The Finale Season of Lost to Debut on February 2nd!
The first episode will kick off with an all-night Lost event.
Steven Spielberg Joins Stephen King Under the Dome
The duo are joining forces to bring King's latest novel to the small screen.
Chuck Returns to NBC on January 10th
The Zachary Levi show will make an early return to the network.
Oprah Winfrey to End Her Show on September 9th, 2011
There is no word on whether she will continue with another version of her show on OWN.
HBO Renews Real Time with Bill Maher for an Eighth Season
The cable show was up 24% during its previous season.
 Click Here! for our complete news archive.