Frank Miller found his claim to fame through the comic book industry as a penciler, writer, and inker. Self-referred to as a visionary, creator, and pioneer, Miller has established his signature appeal through using hard-boiled noil artistic taste. His career in such a competitive artistic environment found its beginnings in his teenage years after bounding between major publishing houses. Miller’s beginnings permitted him to start his journey in comics with some of the largest names in the trade. Aside from his work at DC Comics and Marvel Comics, Miller found a place for himself at Gold Key. His contribution to Spectacular Spider-Man fast-tracked his reputation and his standing with Marvel Comics. Miller became a regular addition to the Daredevil comics production cycle as a penciler before advancing into a writing role for the series. Following his time with Marvel Comics, Miller’s portfolio was able to grow at an exponential rate as he earned more prestigious opportunities for himself. His work on numerous Batman titles has contributed more to the Giallo themes that haunt the Caped Crusader and has transpired across his output thematically in titles such as Sin City.

Comic books have been a force of inspiration when it comes to adapting literary media for the screen. Their endlessly generous means of giving way to hundreds of thousands of stories to share is a clear signal that comic book movies are a staple of modern cinema. Even though superheroes and their foes may be a popular trait found in comics, graphic novelists are only limited by the bounds of their creativity. Comics and graphic novels often echo cornerstone socio-political and economic turning points in history. They are able to articulate pressing issues that are expressed through metaphorical characters and in-world events. Miller has been one among other comic creators who have been cited as the inspiration for comic book movies. His comics have been fortunate enough to undergo the transition from print to cinema. Intense thrillers and gripping narratives have seen both critical praises or fallen by the wayside of infamy as they are tested by the passage of time. Batman v. Superman, Daredevil, and Elektra may not have resulted in a way that parallels Miller’s highly acclaimed work, though fortunately, there are films that capture the essence of what he has been able to achieve as an accomplished industry figure. These are the best movies based on Frank Miller’s comics, ranked.

4 Sin City

sin-city
Troublemaker Studios / Dimension Films

Dripping with violence and teeming with visually stunning shots, Sin City comfortably sinks into the seedy underbelly of Miller’s darker publications. The criminal underworld comes to life with unrelenting metaphorical storytelling. Bothersome in all the right places, Sin City disrespects societal values through sadistic entertainment. Robert Rodriguez unrelentingly dives head-first into Sin City with dramatic macabre in this tour de force homage to Miller’s black-and-white sucker punch. Sin City stuns with its noir overtones that question why the genre isn't as celebrated as it should be. There is great care and consideration taken into how Sin City is perceived through a cinematic interpretation and how it understands that aggression is not completely disarming through a narrative scope. Miller's anthology-style approach to interlinking storylines excellently winds itself around Rodriguez's unique familiarization with the source material at play. It flatters such a striking novel both cinematically and tonally. It rallies a cry that, even as time goes on, that noir filmmaking has not lost its spark.

Related: Will the Comic Book Superhero Movie Genre Still Be Popular in the Next Few Decades?

3 Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Part 1

batman-the-dark-knight-returns-part-1
Warner Bros. Animation

As an unorthodox tale of the Batman’s return to the streets of Gotham takes a daring approach to a darker Batman, this direct-to-video feature is not to be discredited in comparison to its theatrical counterparts. Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 respects the strides that Miller has made around his distinct Batman entries. There has been praise for the political commentary made and the active disillusionment of costumed crime-fighting often seen in a majority of hero-centric stories. Animation and artwork honor the visual aspects of the illustrations found in Miller’s books. Director Jay Olivia naturally enhances Miller’s perception of vigilante justice. Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 speaks on the persistent nature of Bruce Wayne. Age is not an obstacle for The Dark Knight, though Miller's commentary on ageism is a present issue that exists and challenges societal hierarchy. Though the animated feature may underscore dark and suggestive material, the overall execution of how they are communicated permits shock value to be a powerful tool. Hard-hitting narrative direction and impactful character development assist in ensuring that Miller's influence on Batman is not to be forgotten.

2 Batman: Year One

Batman Year One
Warner Bros. Animation

Batman: Year One’s more limited runtime does not threaten the ability to fully capture the elements that made the comic of the same title so compelling. Carried by a skilled voice cast and bound by a complete unification of consistency throughout the film, the nuances of the original comic are found within the animated DC adaptation. Though it can be argued that larger parts of the comic’s original narrative are omitted from the animation, there’s still praise around Batman: Year One understanding that Jim Gordon is just as important as Bruce Wayne. Shared screen time between the two accentuates that Commissioner Gordon is a necessary figure in Batman media and distributes the importance of his role more evenly. There's a more refined look at how corruption has impacted Gotham from multiple angles. Miller's storyline shines in this cinematic reflection of an origin story that reminds audiences that perhaps Batman's beginnings have not overstayed their welcome in comic book media.

Related: Best Comedy Movies Based on Comic Books, Ranked

1 Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Part 2

batman-the-dark-knight-returns-part-2
Warner Bros. Animation

The finale to Miller’s exhilarating Batman: The Dark Knight Returns duet, Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Part 2 creates new standards and expectations for animated superhero films. Miller’s belief that an allegorical figure such as The Batman is deserving of a worthy ending; something that this conclusion delivers upon. Once more, Miller’s visual style bleeds through Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Part 2 to a degree that elevates what the DC Animated Universe is capable of accomplishing. The second-parter is attentive to the needs of Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 and harmonizes with its predecessor. A necessary and unforgettable addition to the infinite collection of Batman media, Warner Bros. insists this is a key piece of animated media that augments Miller’s contributions both on and off of the printed page. Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Part 2 internalizes that comics are given the inherited right to present themselves as political vehicles. The reflection of the comic in print reigns true to messaging put across through a gritter outlook. It remains faithful to Miller's vision while satisfying the accomplishments of the comics, and the recreation of the most intense elevates the appreciation for action that is found at the heart of Miller's Batman books.